Brand Quality Database

Supplement Brand Ratings

Independent quality ratings based on third-party testing, certifications, and transparency. No affiliate links — just honest assessments.

These ratings reflect general brand quality, not individual products. A high-rated brand may still have some mediocre products, and a lower-rated brand may excel in specific categories. Always check third-party test results for the specific product you buy.

Thorne

High Transparency3rd-Party TestedUSA

Frequently used in clinical trials. Strong third-party testing program.

NSF Certified for SportGMPTGA (Australia)

Known for

Vitamin D3Magnesium BisglycinateBasic NutrientsCurcumin Phytosome

Nordic Naturals

High Transparency3rd-Party TestedUSA

Industry leader in fish oil purity and freshness testing.

Friend of the SeaNon-GMO VerifiedGMP

Known for

Omega-3 Fish OilEPADHAVitamin D3

Pure Encapsulations

High Transparency3rd-Party TestedUSA

Free from common allergens, fillers, and additives. Practitioner-grade.

GMPHypoallergenic

Known for

B-ComplexMagnesium GlycinateVitamin D3CoQ10

Nootropics Depot

High Transparency3rd-Party TestedUSA

Gold standard for nootropics and adaptogens. Extensive in-house testing with published CoAs.

In-house and third-party lab testing

Known for

AshwagandhaLion's ManeTongkat AliCistanche

NOW Foods

Medium3rd-Party TestedUSA

Good quality-to-price ratio. Extensive product line.

GMPUL Verified

Known for

Vitamin D3MagnesiumCoQ10Probiotics

Life Extension

High Transparency3rd-Party TestedUSA

Research-focused. Publishes a scientific journal. Good for longevity supplements.

GMPConsumerLab Approved

Known for

NMNNAD+CurcuminVitamin D3 + K2

Jarrow Formulas

Medium3rd-Party TestedUSA

Strong probiotic line. Good formulations at reasonable prices.

GMP

Known for

ProbioticsCoQ10B-ComplexSAMe

Garden of Life

Medium3rd-Party TestedUSA

Focus on whole-food based supplements. Good organic options.

USDA OrganicNon-GMO Project VerifiedNSF Certified

Known for

ProbioticsMultivitaminVitamin D3Collagen
Acquired by Nestlé — some users prefer independent brands

Doctor's Best

Medium3rd-Party TestedUSA

Affordable. Uses branded, trademarked ingredients (e.g., Curcumin C3 Complex).

GMP

Known for

CoQ10CurcuminMagnesiumCollagen

Nutricost

Low3rd-Party TestedUSA

Budget-friendly. Basic formulations without proprietary blends.

GMP

Known for

CreatineAshwagandhaL-TheanineNAC
Limited transparency on sourcing

Rating Methodology

What we look at:

  • Third-party testing (CoAs available)
  • Manufacturing certifications (GMP, NSF)
  • Ingredient sourcing transparency
  • Label accuracy track record
  • Use in clinical research

What we don't factor in:

  • ×Price (we don't sell products)
  • ×Marketing claims
  • ×Amazon reviews
  • ×Influencer endorsements